Skip to main content

Search the Special Collections and Archives Portal

upr000329 123

Image

File
Download upr000329-123.tif (image/tiff; 30.21 MB)

Information

Digital ID

upr000329-123
    Details

    Rights

    This material is made available to facilitate private study, scholarship, or research. It may be protected by copyright, trademark, privacy, publicity rights, or other interests not owned by UNLV. Users are responsible for determining whether permissions are necessary from rights owners for any intended use and for obtaining all required permissions. Acknowledgement of the UNLV University Libraries is requested. For more information, please see the UNLV Special Collections policies on reproduction and use (https://www.library.unlv.edu/speccol/research_and_services/reproductions) or contact us at special.collections@unlv.edu.

    Digital Provenance

    Digitized materials: physical originals can be viewed in Special Collections and Archives reading room

    Publisher

    University of Nevada, Las Vegas. Libraries

    28 IN T E R S T A T E COM M EBCE C O M M IS S IO N EEPOBTS. which the weight certified by the shipper to be correct is so accepted by the carrier. The agreement is in w riting, and provides that the . shipper shall furnish a correct weight, that he w ill pay any addi­tional charges which may be due ow ing to the underweight i f the w eight furnished by him is subsequently corrected, and agreeing to allow the carrier at all times access to all records, invoice books, and papers o f the shipper pertaining to the weights o f the cars shipped. These agreements cover package freigh t put up in standard pack­ages where the weight is determined by counting the number o f pack­ages shipped in a particular car. Th ey also cover freigh t which must be weighed ordinarily in the car by some one. Th is w eighing is done upon the scales o f the industry, which in such cases are under the inspection o f the w eighing bureau, and m ay at any time be tested by the representative o f that bureau. I t sometimes happens that the bureau itself appoints the weighmaster, who is paid bv the industry. Th e ..checks possessed by railroads against underweighing by this practice appear to be twofold. In the first place the w eighing bureau frequently reweighs such cars, comparing the result o f such rew eighing w ith the w eight as fu r­nished by the shipper. W h ile this is not an accurate test, since the weight as given by the shipper in the absence o f intentional fraud would generally be more accurate than that obtainable by the ra il­road from ordinary w eighing upon track scales, still it serves in a rough way to check the correctness o f the shipper’s weight. Secondly, and in the main, the representative o f the w eighing bureau may at any time examine the books and records o f the shipper, and by this means can usually determine whether the amount charged against the customer corresponds w ith the amount rendered to the carrier. The present investigation has not been o f a character to develop any fraudulent practices which may exist under this system. W e have endeavored to ascertain whether complaint o f discrimination exists, either on the ground that the privilege is accorded to some and denied to others or in the administration o f the agreement itself. M ° such instance has been found. A pparen tly the special agreement is extended to all shippers who desire to execute it in certain lines o f business and under certain circumstances without distinction. On the whole, so fa r as we have been able to obtain information, this system is satisfactory to shippers and, i f honestly conducted, tends to secure more accurate weights than could be secured by the ordinary methods o f track-scale' we'ghinn. These special agreements are not, apparently, referred to in the tariff, but all the inspection bureaus publish lists o f the individuals, 28 i. c. C. I I N BE W E IG H IN G OF F \ REIGHT BY CABRIEB. 29 firms, or industries w ith whom such agreements are in force, so that the public is reasonably inform ed o f what is taking place. W here such an agreement is in force in one w eighing district, the weights as furnished by the shipper are ordinarily but not uniform ly accepted in other inspection districts. O f course, the bureau in the district where the traffic originates or any carrier in any other district is free at all times to examine into the correctness o f the w eight o f a par­ticular shipment, and i f found incorrect to advance the shipment to its true weight, and this seems sometimes to be done. T w o or three general rules incorporated in the tariffs o f the car­riers refer to w eighing and have been made the subject o f complaint. The first o f these is what is known as “ tolerance.” I t w ill be readily appreciated that the exact weight o f the contents o f a car can not be ascertained by the use o f track scales. W e have already seen that the scale itself should.be regarded as accurate until an error o f at least 100 pounds is shown. W e have further seen that the tare w eight o f the car is Stated in multiples o f 100 pounds, and is treated as correct unt 1 an error exceeding that amount appears. I t has also been noted that some' o f the coarser commodities which are most frequently the subject o f transportation shrink several hundred pounds in transit. From these and other causes it is admitted on all sides that there must be a lim it o f error within which the ascertained track-scale w eight o f a carload o f freight shall be deemed to be correct. This lim it is known as tolerance, and is in most jurisdictions 500 pounds, but in the jurisdiction o f the Western W eigh in g Associa­tion and Inspection Bureau, which covers most territory on the' west o f the Mississippi R iv er and east o f the Pacific coast states, is 1,000 pounds. In our opinion 1,000 pounds is too great.- In case o f a commodity which only loads 20,000 pounds to the car, and there are many such, it means a twentieth o f the entire loading. Th is is a very significant item in the assessment o f the freigh t charges, and is even more signifi­cant when the question is whether the carrier has delivered the fu ll carload to the consignee. Even in case o f coarser commodities like lumber and coal, weight should be more accurately ascertained than is contemplated b^ this measure o f error. I f one tolerance is to be fixed fo r the w eighing o f all commodities, 500 pounds would seem to be large enough. I t has been suggested that the measure o f tolerance should vary w ith the character o f the commodity transported. E viden tly accu­racy in the matter o f w eight becomes important in proportion to the value o f the article, when the question is as to whether the entire carload has been delivered, and in proportion to the amount o f the rate, when the question concerns merely the assessment o f freigh t 28 I C. O.